The World | • Updated | By
“AKI for All” Season 2 Sunday, October 5, opponents of gay marriage will return to the streets for an event to be attended by a number of elected members of the UMP, but the National Front. With a new slogan: not only for the removal of the Taubira law, and thus the repeal of gay marriage but also against surrogacy (surrogacy) and PMA (assisted reproduction) for gay couples.
“What we want is to repeal the law without Taubira retroactively ban the LDCs for same-sex couples and surrogacy and oust ideology sort out our schools and organizations where it has nothing to do “says Ludovine de la Rochere, a leader of the movement
As many slogans that raise questions. further that killing gay marriage seems more legally risky, the issues of GPA and LDCs, for all AKI seems to have forgotten the law. As for “gender ideology”, it falls largely fantasy.
1 . Taubira law would repeal the more complex
There were, in early 2014, about 7000 sex marriages celebrated in France and dozens of adoptions by couples. How, under these conditions, repeal Taubira law? Manif for all makes it clear she does not want feedback, that is to say, “thinning” of stable marriages. What would be legally absurd. Also imagine this marriage transform equivalent status
Read. Returned to power, could it come back right on gay marriage?
But even repeal marriage for all would be more complex. This would create a de facto inequality between people who have married before the law and the people who could most, which could be likened to a “breach of equality before the law.” . Well with the high probability that a couple aggrieved is doing before the European Court of Human Rights
It should also take into account the political impact of such a decision: several surveys show that a clear majority of French – even among supporters of the UMP – is not conducive to a questioning of homosexual unions. Repeal gay marriage would most likely have a negative political impact for the majority who make the decision. Historically, as pointed out by constitutional Didier Maus, “there was never any turning back on reforms of society since the Liberation” .
2 . The GPA is still not allowed
Second point: “the universal prohibition” of the GPA. The anti-marriage have made the practice of the GPA (which is to “carry” a child by another woman, from the egg most often the mother and being fertilized by the intended father, but can also come an anonymous donor or biological mother) a foil, saying that was “ Trade bellies” of women or babies. Taubira law was never properly planned or planned at any time during the hearing.
GPA, be it homosexual or heterosexual, whether paid or not, is prohibited France and always has been. The anti-marriage in fact refer to the issue of a judgment of the European Court of Human Rights, about the famous husband Mennesson. The heterosexual couple, infertile, had used a GPA practiced in California, where it is legal. They were given binoculars, and the American justice granted them the status of parents of two little girls.
But back in France, they were refused by the state to grant citizenship French for children, and a transmission case to the prosecutor on suspicion of GPA. A judge issued an order of dismissal, the facts that occurred abroad, in an area where they were not allowed. There followed a lengthy court battle over the nationality of the two girls, who remained in the custody of their parents also. The ECHR ruled, condemning France for breach of Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which imposes the ‘right to respect for family life. “
The judgment of the ECHR does not legalize the practice of the GPA on the French territory
This judgment, which s’ required by French law, should lead judges to recognize in the future that we can not condemn the child as the result of non-compliance by their parents. So you can not refuse nationality or adoption due to the way of conception of the child abroad. This judgment is therefore not absolutely legalizes the practice of surrogacy on the French territory and does not prevent the legislature to condemn the parents on that basis
In practice, it changes little. Both twins living with their parents. And if a foreign court has acknowledged parentage of a child born through surrogacy and his father, in the case of a gay couple, the French justice does not remove the child and it does not have jurisdiction to convict a practice done legally in a foreign country. The only change is that it could, for example, longer refuse an adoption of the child conceived by the companion of the father on the grounds of the GPA.
Read : GPA, PMA, what impact will the decision of the ECHR on the French right?
As for the ban “universal”, she returned to the AKI for all to ask several countries to give up a legal practice on their soil for years. Manuel Valls and just go in his direction by explaining that he intended to ask Laurent Fabius that France bears a claim to its neighbors that foreign couples do not have access to surrogacy in countries that allow it .
3 . PMA for gay couples is still not permitted, nor
The prohibition of LDCs for same-sex couples is under the same principle: AKI for all claims in fact that is already banned . In France, the PMA (artificial insemination of the mother, including via in vitro fertilization) is permitted only for clinically infertile heterosexual couples or whose one member is suffering from a serious disease that could be transmitted to the child. The government had planned to open a time PMA couples lesbians wishing birth. He agreed.
In practice, the PMA is very complex in France, mainly due to low number of egg donation. Long, heterosexual couples therefore depart in neighboring countries, Spain and the Netherlands in particular, where it is easier to access. For a long time also, pairs of lesbians are getting the same approach and abroad access to artificial insemination.
This is illegal in France. And this has not changed since 2012 Again, we can not prevent heterosexual or homosexual from countries where it is legal couples. With the return of the same parentage issues facing the legislature. The judgment of the ECHR in the case should Mennesson de facto harmonization of court decisions on adoption by the spouse of a child of LDCs, which are currently quite different from one jurisdiction to another . But in practice, this does not change: the PMA is not allowed in France, same-sex couples
4 <. / span>. “The ideology of gender” in school is a fantasy
Finally, the famous “gender ideology”. Explained many times, this concept was coined by his critics, who mix a variety of different things.
notion of “gender” commune. This notion differs from sex in the sense that it takes into account the social roles of men and women. Used by many international organizations such as the World Health Organization, it is the basis for many sociological studies, some of which are practical political application: the fight against gender inequality
Read: Male-female, five myths about gender studies
It is this struggle that the government wanted to promote through including “ABCD equality” launched pilot program in some schools, and abandoned since
Read. “Gender theory, ten links to include”
Transform “ideology” or “theory.” for all AKI has attached various concepts, from the academic literature, American feminists, including Judith Butler, bane of “anti-gender”. These sociological studies have worked on the construction of “gender identity” which means for example that a little boy is dancing, or a little girl who makes rugby, going to strange or unusual; or that “expects” a woman softer than a man’s character. We’re talking about university, which thus questioning these and the “place” given to men and women, “gender studies.”
There is no” gender ideology “that resemble the Marxist ideology
But there is no” gender ideology “that resemble the Marxist ideology, the meaning of a single political theory, with a clear agenda and a desire to change society in a precise and established protocol. The fight against discrimination and for equality between men and women is nothing new. It is an educational objective assumed by the official texts of Education for twenty years. It is also an EU target, even global, in the sense that it is supported by UNICEF and the UN
Read our decryption. “Five disinformation about the” theory like “”
Most importantly, the French schools have no program for children transfomer hermaphrodites, or even introduce them to the academic study of the concept of gender. Some programs aim primarily to question stereotypes, and teach children a woman can become a helicopter pilot and father house-husband, without it being a deviant.
It is estimated that is not the role of the school. But this notion of “theory” or “ideology” of gender is largely a fantasy building from a hard core of AKI for all, composed of traditionalist Catholics or personalities of the sulfur, as the artisan “Days of withdrawal from school,” Farida Belghoul near the extreme right conspiracy Alain Soral.
No comments:
Post a Comment